Port McNicoll, Tay MLS Listings & Real Estate For Sale

SHOW MAP

Showing 1 to 30 of 33 listings

New
For Sale

379 Wardell Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3+1 Bedrooms
2 Bath
700-1100 sq ft
2 Garage

New
For Sale

753 Fifth Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
3 Bath
1100-1500 sq ft
2 Garage

New
For Sale

480 Broderick Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3+2 Bedrooms
2 Bath
1100-1500 sq ft

New
For Sale

244/250 Dignard Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

2 Bedrooms
1 Bath
700-1100 sq ft

For Sale

7 Dock Lane

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
3 Bath
2000-2500 sq ft
2 Garage

For Sale

5 Easton Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

2+1 Bedrooms
2 Bath
1100-1500 sq ft
2 Garage

For Sale

366 Talbot Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
1 Bath
700-1100 sq ft

For Sale

196 PARADISE Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

2 Bedrooms
1 Bath
700-1100 sq ft

For Sale

757 Fourth Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

7 Bedrooms
4 Bath
2000-2500 sq ft

For Sale

40-76 DOCK Lane

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

For Sale

528 First Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
2 Bath
1100-1500 sq ft
3 Garage

For Sale

679 Simcoe Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

5 Bedrooms
2 Bath
700-1100 sq ft
6 Garage

For Sale

503 Margaret Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

< 700 sq ft

For Sale

817 Eighth Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

2 Bedrooms
1 Bath
700-1100 sq ft

For Sale

Lot 86-548 Fifth Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

For Sale

15 Swan Lane

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

< 700 sq ft

For Sale

363 Wardell Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3+2 Bedrooms
2 Bath
1100-1500 sq ft
1 Garage

For Sale

475 Athabaska Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3+1 Bedrooms
2 Bath
700-1100 sq ft
2 Garage

For Sale

461 Barnes Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3+2 Bedrooms
2 Bath
1100-1500 sq ft
1 Garage

For Sale

10 & 11 Methodist Island

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

4 Bedrooms
1 Bath
700-1100 sq ft

For Sale

58 Methodist Island

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
2 Bath
1100-1500 sq ft

For Sale

440 David Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

For Sale

14 Earldom Boulevard

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

2 Bedrooms
1 Bath
700-1100 sq ft

For Sale

27-53 Dock Lane

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

4 Bedrooms
3 Bath
3000-3500 sq ft
2 Garage

For Sale

740 Midland Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
3 Bath
2000-2500 sq ft
2 Garage

For Sale

247 Dignard Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

For Sale

401 McNicoll Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

For Sale

2 Swan Lane

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

3 Bedrooms
3 Bath
3000-3500 sq ft
2 Garage

For Sale

505 Helen Duncan Street

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

For Sale

230 Dignard Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

Recently Sold in Port McNicoll, Tay Buildings in Port McNicoll, Tay

Townhouse Condo Detached Semi-Detached Luxury Homes Luxury Condos

Overview of Port McNicoll, Tay Real Estate Market & MLS® Listings

Here is a quick overview of Port McNicoll, Tay Real Estate Market & MLS Listings by Home Type in the last 12 months.

Detached Houses Real Estate Market Snapshot for Port McNicoll, Tay

The average price of a detached houses in Port McNicoll, Tay was $462,500 for the month of September, 2026

Price Changes

Compared to last month: Price has increased by 18% for detached houses in Port McNicoll, Tay.
Over the last 3 months: Price has increased by 15% for detached houses in Port McNicoll, Tay.
Over the last 12 months ending in September, 2026: Price has increased by 8% for detached houses in Port McNicoll, Tay.

Market Activity for Detached Houses in Port McNicoll, Tay

Selling time: On average, it takes 81 days to sell a detached houses in Port McNicoll, Tay, while same time last year it took 35 days to sell a detached houses.
Active Listings: Currently, there are 21 detached houses available for sale in Port McNicoll, Tay.
Recent Sales:
- In the month of September, 2026, 2 detached houses were sold in Port McNicoll, Tay, compared to 4 detached houses sold in the same month last year. This represents a 50% decreased in sales.

View Sold Detached Houses in Port McNicoll, Tay

List Price vs. Sold Price in Port McNicoll, Tay

$529,450 is the average list price for detached houses in Port McNicoll, Tay for the month of September, 2026.
Detached Houses are currently selling for 87% of their asking price in Port McNicoll, Tay. For example, if a house is listed at $1 million, it will likely sell for around $0.87 million.

FAQs about City/Community Real Estate

How do I find the Value of my House in Port McNicoll, Tay?

It's simple! Give us a call at 647-276-5100, and we'll come to you for a free, in-person home valuation. One of our experienced real estate agents will visit your property and provide you with the most accurate, up-to-date market value based on local trends and insights. Prefer a digital option? You can also use our Home Value Estimator by clicking here, and we'll send you regular updates on your home's market value every month!

How much will you charge to sell my house or condo?

Our commission packages are designed to offer exceptional value while remaining competitive and flexible. We understand that every client and property is unique, so our commission structure is negotiable and tailored to meet your specific needs. Our listing fee can range from 1% to 2.5%. Our priority is to deliver outstanding service, marketing, and results to help you achieve your real estate goals. Feel free to give us a call and ask about our current promotions at 647-576-2100.

What Type of Marketing Do You Use to Sell Homes?

I utilize a comprehensive marketing strategy to ensure your home gets maximum exposure and attracts the right buyers. My approach includes:

Professional Photography & Videography: High-quality visuals to showcase your home. Check out some of our listing videos on YouTube as they have over 20k view on them, where we target buyers looking to purchase in your area.
Staging Consultations &/or Staging: Tips to present your home at its best.
Targeted Online Advertising: Campaigns on social media and property listing websites to reach potential buyers.
Email Marketing: Reaching out to a network of qualified buyers and agents.
Traditional Marketing: Flyers, brochures, and open houses to connect with local buyers.

Learn more about how I can market your property effectively here: Full Marketing Plan to sell your Home/Condo

How much do you charge to help me buy a house?

As a buyer, you typically don’t pay any commission for our services. In most cases, the seller covers the real estate commission for both their agent and the buyer’s agent. This means you get full professional support — at no cost to you — while we help you find the perfect home, negotiate the best deal, and guide you through the entire process. Call 647-576-2100 to find out our latest promotions for buyers.

What is the first step in buying a home in Port McNicoll, Tay?

The first step in your home-buying journey is to get pre-approved for a mortgage. This not only helps you determine your budget but also gives you a clear idea of what you can afford before you start house hunting. Need guidance? Check out this article where we walk you through each step of the process! Click Here

What is the average detached house price in Port McNicoll, Tay?

Average detached house price in Port McNicoll, Tay is $450,871. Click here to check out detached homes for sale in Port McNicoll, Tay.

What are the average property taxes for homes and condos in Port McNicoll, Tay?

The average property taxes vary based on the type of home in Port McNicoll, Tay for the last 12 months:

Detached House: $2,079

These figures provide an estimate of what homeowners can expect to pay annually in property taxes on an average house or condo in Port McNicoll, Tay. Property taxes will vary depending on the property value, property type, location, size, zoning and many other factors.

How much land transfer tax do I have to pay to buy a house in Port McNicoll, Tay?

The average price of a house in Port McNicoll, Tay is $450,871, which means you can expect to pay approximately $5,492 in land transfer tax at closing. However, if you're a first-time homebuyer, you may qualify for a rebate of up to $4,000, making homeownership more affordable.

Land transfer tax in Ontario is $4,475 for properties priced at $400,000. For amounts exceeding $400,000, the tax is 2% up to $2 million, and 2.5% for amounts over $2 million. If you’re buying a home in Toronto times that figure by 2 because Toronto is the only municipality charging Land Transfer Tax.

Your privacy is of the utmost importance to us. Below, we explain how we use the information you provide us with. Changes may be made to our privacy policy in the future, we recommend that you periodically review it.

Your Data

Data will not be sold or shared with third parties for promotional or marketing purposes.

Your Name

We use your name for no reason other than to greet you when we send you a message on behalf of your real estate agent.

Your Email Address

We use your email address to email you messages on behalf of your real estate agent. If your preference is not to receive email messages you may turn off email notifications in your preferences. If you wish to unsubscribe from receiving future messages from us on behalf of your real estate agent you may click unsubscribe at the bottom of any email you receive.

Your Phone Number

We use your phone number to text you messages on behalf of your real estate agent. If your preference is not to receive text messages you may turn off text notifications in your preferences. If you wish to unsubscribe from receiving future messages from us on behalf of your real estate agent you may text STOP in response to any text message you receive.

Your Search Preferences

Your real estate agent provides us with your search preferences. We use this information to inform you of new listings that you may be interested in. You may delete your search preferences at any time by clicking filters.

Properties You've Viewed

We keep track of the properties that you view. This helps us understand what properties you're interested in so that we may keep you informed when the property information changes. We also allow your real estate agent to see what properties you've viewed so that they may better serve you.

Properties You've Liked

We keep track of the properties that you've liked. This is for your convenience. We also allow your real estate agent to view properties you've liked so that they may better serve you.

Properties You've Disliked

We keep track of the properties that you've disliked. We also allow your real estate agent to view properties you've disliked so that they may better serve you.

Messages and Conversations

Messages and conversations between you and your real estate agent may be viewed by other members of your real estate agent's team.

We use cookies to improve your experience. Cookies allow us to keep you logged in so that you don't have to provide a username and password each time you visit this website.

Your Real Estate Agent

Your real estate agent is required to abide by the Privacy Code of the Canadian Real Estate Association. For specific information, please view the following PDF: http://www.mcsres.com/shared/PrivacyPolicy.pdf

Please read this agreement carefully before using this website or accessing services offered through this website. In using this website, you agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge that it's your responsibility to periodically review the Terms of Use for changes and amendments.

Visitors of this website
In using this website or services offered by this website, you are entering into a lawful broker-consumer relationship with Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc., Brokerage.

This website and its services are intended for use by non-commercial buyers and sellers of Real Estate. You must have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered through this website. Any commercial use of this website, and/or its services is strictly prohibited unless otherwise authorized in writing by Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc., Brokerage.

You use this website and the services offered by this website at your own risk. The content on this website and the services offered by this website are provided "as is" without warranty. In no circumstance will Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc., Brokerage, be held liable for damages of any kind arising from the use of this website or services offered by this website.

This website, including its content, and design may not be reproduced or distributed in any form. All content on this website is owned by Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc., Brokerage, and all rights are reserved.

You may not, directly or indirectly, display, post, disseminate, distribute, publish, broadcast, transfer, sell or sublicense any Listing Information to another individual or entity. The prohibited uses expressly include “scraping” (including “screen scraping” and “database scraping”), “data mining” or any other activity intended to collect, store, re-organize, summarize or manipulate any Listing Information or any related data.

You may not copy, redistribute, retransmit, or otherwise use any of the data or Listing Information provided, except in connection with your consideration of the purchase or sale of an individual property.

You acknowledge TRREB’s ownership of, and the validity of TRREB’s proprietary rights and copyright in, the MLS® database, TRREB’s MLS® System, Listing Information, and any related information.

TRREB, and other Members of TRREB or their duly authorized representatives may access this website for the purposes of verifying compliance with MLS® Rules and Policies (including the VOW Rules) and monitoring the display of Members’ Listings by the VOW.

You acknowledge ITSO's ownership of, and the validity of ITSO's proprietary rights and copyright in, the MLS® database, ITSO's MLS® System, Listing Information and any related information.

ITSO, and other Members of ITSO or their duly authorized representatives may access this website for the purposes of verifying compliance with MLS® Rules and Policies (including the VOW Rules) and monitoring the display of Members' Listings by the VOW.

CLOSE MAP

Port McNicoll, Tay MLS Listings & Real Estate For Sale

Port McNicoll, Tay MLS Listings & Real Estate For Sale

SORRY, NO PROPERTIES WERE FOUND THAT MATCH YOUR SEARCH.

Detached Houses Real Estate Market Snapshot for Port McNicoll, Tay

Price Changes

Market Activity for Detached Houses in Port McNicoll, Tay

List Price vs. Sold Price in Port McNicoll, Tay

FAQs about City/Community Real Estate

Nearby Neighborhoods

Buy

Quick Links